GStwin.com GS500 Message Forum

Main Area => General GS500 Discussion => Topic started by: Ammanas on September 09, 2005, 11:29:01 AM

Title: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: Ammanas on September 09, 2005, 11:29:01 AM
Hi, new GS owner, and new to motorcycling. I bought a 2001 GS500E a couple weeks ago. I haven't take it out yet (waiting till I do the MSF program in a week) but I've been 'practicing' shifting on a flat surface, not moving much.

When I try to shift 'down' from neutral to first, most of the time the bike dies upon pressing the pedal. Then the shifting pedal 'locks' and I have to move the bike back and forth a few feet to get it to unlock so I can go back to neutral. However it doesn't ALWAYS do this. Sometimes I can shift 'down' into first with no big problem (although at times it seems the bike 'lurches' foward a bit excessively; my brothers Ninja 250 doesn't move at all when shifting).

I thought it might be that I was accidentally moving the kickstand down and releasing pressure from the safety switch that prevents riding while the kickstand is down, but unless i'ts really sensitive or something I don't believe that to be the problem.

Any ideas?
Title: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: dionysus on September 09, 2005, 11:30:56 AM
ehmm. are you pulling the clutch in?
Title: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: davipu on September 09, 2005, 11:31:29 AM
clutch adjustment too far out? old crappy oil?
Title: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: Ammanas on September 09, 2005, 11:31:57 AM
Quote from: dionysusehmm. are you pulling the clutch in?

yes, to a degree I think is a bit excessive but maybe Im just not used to it (I pull it really hard until its essentially flat against the grip).

Quote from: davipuclutch adjustment too far out? old crappy oil?

Could you explain what you mean about the clutch adjustment being too far out? I believe the oil is fairly fresh.
Title: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: davipu on September 09, 2005, 11:34:42 AM
if ther is too much slack in the cable you can't pull the lever far enough back to allow the clutch to release the pressure.
Title: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: davipu on September 09, 2005, 11:36:45 AM
http://www.bbburma.net/
Title: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: dmanben on September 09, 2005, 11:47:52 AM
sorry edited after reading closer.
Title: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: Ammanas on September 09, 2005, 11:52:33 AM
Quote from: davipuhttp://www.bbburma.net/

In the video, Kerry's clutch seems to be able to barely move before hitting a limit. Despite adjusting mine to both extremes, little difference was found and nothing even near his level of tightness. The only difference I've noticed was that holding the clutch in became a bit harder to do.
Title: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: Chuck on September 09, 2005, 12:03:02 PM
With the bike in gear, and the engine not running, you're probably not able to move the bike forward or backward without the rear wheel skidding.

Squeeze the clutch lever, and try again to roll the bike forward and backward.  Does it roll?  This will tell you if the clutch is even working at all.
Title: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: rritterson on September 09, 2005, 12:10:29 PM
I agree with everyone else. Something is wrong with your clutch and/or cable.

I would try two things- contacting the old owner and ask if he ever had troubles, and riding your bro's 250 and see if you can shift that.
Title: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: Ammanas on September 09, 2005, 12:36:27 PM
Quote from: ChuckWith the bike in gear, and the engine not running, you're probably not able to move the bike forward or backward without the rear wheel skidding.

Squeeze the clutch lever, and try again to roll the bike forward and backward.  Does it roll?  This will tell you if the clutch is even working at all.

Yes, it rolls when I pull the clutch in  in first gear, with the engine off. It's a bit stiff/hard to push, but it rolls. It rolls fine in neutral.
Title: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: Ammanas on September 09, 2005, 12:39:38 PM
Quote from: rrittersonI agree with everyone else. Something is wrong with your clutch and/or cable.

I would try two things- contacting the old owner and ask if he ever had troubles, and riding your bro's 250 and see if you can shift that.

I have tried shifting his Ninja, albiet in place (same as with the GS) and it shifts smooth as buttter (it made me really jealous!).
Title: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: xtalman on September 09, 2005, 12:55:04 PM
You can adjust the clutch cable at two places, can't you?  At the handlebar and near the engine cover?
Title: Re: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: TarzanBoy on September 09, 2005, 12:59:27 PM
I don't know what is causing your bike to shut down, but the lurching problem does at least sound like a clutch issue.   HOWEVER, I think i can help you with your shift-into-first problem.

If you are ever stopped in neutral, and your shifter/bike decides that it doesn't want to get into first then here is a trick to get it into first without rocking it back and forth

With the brake engaged/depressed:

-Keep your left foot on the shifter and apply downward pressure just as you would while attempting to downshift.

-With your left hand, gradually let the clutch out while still maintaining pressure on the shifter

-By time the clutch is 1/3-2/3 of the way out, the bike should gracefully shift into first gear.

-Depress the clutch immediately after the bike shifts to avoid starting off and/or stalling

Its a trick that my roommate taught me.  It sure comes in handy at stoplights.  What you're doing is putting the bike into the edge of the friction zone in order to get the gears to 'sync up' to shift much more easily.
Title: Re: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: Ammanas on September 09, 2005, 03:20:36 PM
Quote from: TarzanBoyI don't know what is causing your bike to shut down, but the lurching problem does at least sound like a clutch issue.   HOWEVER, I think i can help you with your shift-into-first problem.

Well maybe I did it wrong but all that happened was the engine died and the pedal locked. :)
Title: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: ratz on September 09, 2005, 03:25:17 PM
This may be a silly question, but, lets start with the simple stuff.
Do you have the kickstand down?

With the kickstand down, as you shift into gear, it will die.

Correct me if I am wrong......
Anyone...
Title: Re: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: TarzanBoy on September 09, 2005, 03:59:43 PM
Quote from: Ammanas
Quote from: TarzanBoyI don't know what is causing your bike to shut down, but the lurching problem does at least sound like a clutch issue.   HOWEVER, I think i can help you with your shift-into-first problem.

Well maybe I did it wrong but all that happened was the engine died and the pedal locked. :)

Did you stall the engine out?   If you can't tell whether you stalled the engine out or whether your bike is malfunctioning then you probably should not be riding it on the streets with any kind of traffic :-/
Title: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: Ammanas on September 09, 2005, 04:15:41 PM
Quote from: ratzThis may be a silly question, but, lets start with the simple stuff.
Do you have the kickstand down?

With the kickstand down, as you shift into gear, it will die.

Correct me if I am wrong......
Anyone...

No, I don't have the kickstand down. It is however a possibility the sensor is getting tripped or something, but it doesn't seem that way.

QuoteDid you stall the engine out?   If you can't tell whether you stalled the engine out or whether your bike is malfunctioning then you probably should not be riding it on the streets with any kind of traffic :-/

Why do you think I'm not riding anywhere at all yet, let alone in "any kind of traffic"? It doesn't seem very helpful to come into a thread asking for help then be condescending.
Title: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: Narcissus on September 09, 2005, 05:44:14 PM
When I got my GS the shifting lever was a bit loose and I'd really have to give it a good kick to get it to shift down into 1st. The kickstand safety switch might be a possibilty, but I wouldn't think it would move when your foot is on top of the lever, maybe when you're upshifting if you wear large boots.
Title: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: ajgs500 on September 09, 2005, 06:01:23 PM
My sidestand is messed up so that sometimes even if it is up and I shift down to first from neutral the bike dies.  This only happens when I am sitting still usually after I have just gotten on and or warmed up the bike.  Make sure the spring is not stretched out.
Title: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: Ammanas on September 09, 2005, 06:44:21 PM
looks like you might be right aj. i jury-rigged the kickstand up and secured and put the bike on the center stand. it shifted ok and didn't die. the kickstand appears to wiggle laterally  - perhaps the bushing is loose and needs to be replaced so the kickstand unit can't wiggle around. i shall investigate further!
Title: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: Kerry on September 10, 2005, 10:11:01 AM
Quote from: Ammanas
Quote from: davipuhttp://www.bbburma.net/
In the video, Kerry's clutch seems to be able to barely move before hitting a limit.
It doesn't really hit a limit; I just didn't pull on it much.  (Good observation!  I need to reshoot that video anyway....)  Like you, I can pull the clutch lever all the way to the handlebar no matter how it's adjusted.

I agree about the sidestand switch ... or rather, about the sidestand itself being "lazy" and dropping a bit on its own.  Let us know what your further investigation turns up.  :)
Title: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: Ammanas on September 10, 2005, 12:48:59 PM
Quote from: Kerry
Quote from: Ammanas
Quote from: davipuhttp://www.bbburma.net/
In the video, Kerry's clutch seems to be able to barely move before hitting a limit.
It doesn't really hit a limit; I just didn't pull on it much.  (Good observation!  I need to reshoot that video anyway....)  Like you, I can pull the clutch lever all the way to the handlebar no matter how it's adjusted.

I agree about the sidestand switch ... or rather, about the sidestand itself being "lazy" and dropping a bit on its own.  Let us know what your further investigation turns up.  :)

Thanks for clearing that up. I've since realized what "freeplay" actually means and found the difference to be noticable when I adjust the cable according to your video (video tutorials rock by the way).

I put it up on the center stand, and guess what: it shifts fine. The thing is, even with the clutch pulled in fully, the rear tire is spinning once I leave neutral, which, as far as I understand motorcycles (:P) should NOT be happening.

I'm still a little suspicious about that kickstand though. It wiggles and seems way too lose when flipped up, even with the nut/bolt tight as they can be.
Title: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: rritterson on September 10, 2005, 02:28:08 PM
was your bike ever stunted? Your clutch sounds like it's slipping, which usually means something is worn to the limit. Since it's only an 01 (right?), that seems a little fast.
Title: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: Ammanas on September 11, 2005, 12:39:22 AM
Quote from: rrittersonwas your bike ever stunted? Your clutch sounds like it's slipping, which usually means something is worn to the limit. Since it's only an 01 (right?), that seems a little fast.

Not as far as I know. The previous owner was an older guy who drives a cruiser, but he got it from his brother. It only has 9000 miles.

Should I just take the bike into the shop (even though I can't really afford it :().
Title: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: TheGoodGuy on September 11, 2005, 02:28:48 AM
let me have a look at it. I will come by and check it out. I live off Howe/50.
Title: Shifting problem; what am i doing [wrong]
Post by: Ammanas on September 11, 2005, 02:47:20 AM
Quote from: The_good_guylet me have a look at it. I will come by and check it out. I live off Howe/50.

That'd be awesome. Drop me an email at awisner@frontiernet.net and I'll give ya my address.