GStwin.com GS500 Message Forum

Main Area => General GS500 Discussion => Topic started by: ScottWV on January 18, 2004, 10:54:36 AM

Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: ScottWV on January 18, 2004, 10:54:36 AM
I saw in a recent post that JamesG mentioned he has a YZF600R, and rather than hijack the thread I thought I'd start a new one.  :)

So, for JamesG, and anybody else who has owned/ridden one, what do you think?  I'm just curious.  Don't have money for a new bike right now, but it's one I keep looking at for the future if I go the full-fairing route.  So all opinions, etc. would be very much appreciated.

Thanks!
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: JamesG on January 18, 2004, 11:10:25 AM
Other than it is IMHO the world's best all-arounder, jack-of-all-trades (but master o' none) bike today, what do you want to know?
:)
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: Kokopellian on January 18, 2004, 04:03:59 PM
I think I'm getting one.  I rode one recently and it convinced me enough to get one over the SV650.  It's more comfortable than the SV650 to me.  Also, it's WAY cheaper than a Honda Interceptor!  I really like them.
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: yamahonkawazuki on January 18, 2004, 06:08:45 PM
yeah, im contemplating selling my gs, actually trade for pick-up, w/ new motor, (my truck needs one), and buying 97 model yzf from friend. i actully like it, somewhat comfortable, and handles well.
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: ScottWV on January 19, 2004, 09:54:26 AM
Quote from: JamesGOther than it is IMHO the world's best all-arounder, jack-of-all-trades (but master o' none) bike today, what do you want to know?
:)

Generally everything i've read/seen is good, except I hear there's an issue with the 1-2 shift under power.  Have you had trouble with 2nd gear?
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: juggernaught on January 19, 2004, 11:16:49 AM
I haven't ridden the FZ6 but i'm keeping my eye on it.  I've researched it on the net as i'm hoping to get a new bike this spring.  I was looking at the FZ6 and the Honda 599 which i also think is sweet. I found a few sites that review the two.  I was considering the SV650 but pretty much ruled it out over the first 2.  The Honda goes for about $7,100 which is kinda steep but anyone i've spoken to who rides a Honda swears by their reliability.  Still the FZ6 is mighty pretty.  ANd the 599 looks like a GS on steroids....decisions decisions...

Here are a couple of links:

http://www.motorcyclistonline.com/firstrides/122_0312_yamfz6/

http://www.amasuperbike.com/2003-Oct/031013599.htm

FYI...

My 2002 GS needs a bit of work but i intend to sell it after having it fixed up.  I'll keep you guys in mind when i decide to finally sell it.

:thumb: [/url]
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: juggernaught on January 19, 2004, 11:18:00 AM
Oops....ya'll were talking about the YZF.....doh..!!!

Nevermind  :oops:
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: JamesG on January 19, 2004, 11:49:02 AM
Quote from: ScottWVGenerally everything i've read/seen is good, except I hear there's an issue with the 1-2 shift under power.  Have you had trouble with 2nd gear?

Yep, thats why I don't recommend the bike to novice riders. Besides the fact is has lots of expensive plastics, the bike has a tendency to miss shifts to 2nd unless you are forceful with the shifter. Missing gives it a false neutral and can grind up the gear dogs.  The Factory Pro "shift kit" (really a stronger detent spring), helps, but its still a bug of the transmission design. Once you know about it, and how to avoid it, its not  a problem.
Other than that the bike has no other problems, its a good comfortable sport bike. So journeyman that it verges on the bland.  The after market is kinda hit or miss on it though, you can find stuff, but it takes some digging to find. Like I've been trying to fit hard sidebags to mine, but GIVI or anyone else doesn't make a mount for the YZF, so I'm going to fabricate one for it myself.
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: alerbaugh on January 19, 2004, 06:26:52 PM
I've had my eye on the yzf600r for a gfew weeks.  Would you guys say it's a good second bike.  I'm looking for 70-90 hp but more is ok; and easily hits and stays at 80mph+.  I would keep this bike awile as well.  This or another 600 but insurance is a bear on we 17 year olds.  Any gripes about them?
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: ScottWV on January 19, 2004, 07:38:49 PM
Speaking of insurance, I hope just because it's a 600cc 4cyl that the insurance companies don't charge outrageous amounts to insure it...
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: vtlion on January 19, 2004, 07:44:26 PM
I suppose it depends on your insurance company, but my gut feeling is that it'll get lumped in with the Gixxers and CBR's because of its styling... not to mention that the 600R has about 85-90% the HP of an R6.

Good luck with it.  let us know if you find someone who will cut you a break on insurance for it.
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: alerbaugh on January 19, 2004, 08:35:01 PM
Not sure if it's a local company but Farmers sells motorcycle insurance with a car by engine size.  It has nothing to do with how they look or how fast they go but but pure engine size.  like 450-599cc is one and 600-749 is another size.  so 1cc does make a differance but I don't know how much you pay for it.  If I had a car I would get it but they don't insure motorcycles only. :x
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: Frost on January 19, 2004, 09:19:29 PM
there's a review of the YZF600 and the ZZR600 in this month's Cycle Canada...
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: pantablo on January 19, 2004, 11:54:47 PM
Quote from: alerbaughNot sure if it's a local company but Farmers sells motorcycle insurance with a car by engine size.  It has nothing to do with how they look or how fast they go but but pure engine size.  
. :x

AAA sells insurance and quotes their motorcycles by engine size. Upgrading from a 01 gs500 to a 03 triumph speed four (a i4 "600" but its 599cc) only adds $94/YEAR.
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: alerbaugh on January 20, 2004, 06:20:16 AM
does AAA do motorcycles only? :)
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: bigdaub on January 21, 2004, 12:53:43 PM
i had an 03 and i liked the bike, no problems and rides comfortably.  definately big power difference between the gs and the 600, and clutch is really sensitive.  don't have it any more, sold it to my cusin recently, and he loves it.

the hornet is sweet.  haven't had the change to ride it yet but from what i've heard is that it handles really well.
Title: Re: YZF600R
Post by: lumpoffire on January 21, 2004, 06:48:50 PM
I had a '97 YZF.  Nice bike all around; fast, good handling, even good mileage.  The riding position just didn't agree with me, even after installing Helibars.  This bike is supposedly more comfortable than the current race-replicas like CBR-RRs, R6s, GSX-Rs, etc.  It still felt low to me.  If you're short of arm like I am, it might be a problem, especially after riding a comfy standard style bike like the GS500E.  Also, bikes should have centerstands, like the good Lord intended.

Dan
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: jag69 on January 26, 2004, 03:37:26 PM
James G... Please list some pros and cons of the YZF600.  I would like it as a second bike.  More specifcally, How is the wind protection on the Highway?  How touchy is the throttle compared to the GS?  Is it difficult to maneuver in city traffic?  Sport-Touring?  These are just a few to begin with.

Thanks,
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: JamesG on January 26, 2004, 07:08:16 PM
Well...
Wind protection is excellent and the relatively heavy weight (compared to "modern" 600s) make it very stable on the highway.  It makes a very good sport tourer for single riding. It doesn't have the umph of a big liter bike but its alot more manuverable than one.
A GS is a MUCH better bike for city riding and traffic manuvering. The YZF is a bit of a porker at low speed and its throttle is pretty rough at just off idle, but that could just be the stock jetting. Once you get used to it, its ok and the rest of the bike's charm makes up for that sin.
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: jag69 on January 26, 2004, 10:22:08 PM
Thanks.  Was it difficult to get used to after riding the GS?  I have full fairing nerves.  I will continue my research.

Thanks again.
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: JamesG on January 27, 2004, 06:30:31 AM
Not really, it was a little different coming off an SV though.
GS and YZF (or any I-4) have similar power bands, just more of it.

Yes, I fret about the fairing too, the YZF has ALOT of plastic.  But (knock on wood) I've been riding long enough, that I've stopped tipping my bikes over.
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: jag69 on January 27, 2004, 08:55:36 AM
Thanks.  I am still torn between Honda 599 or YZF600r.  To stay naked or not.  That is the question.
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: JamesG on January 27, 2004, 09:58:42 AM
All depends on what you want to use it for and what you *need*.

IMO- The 599 is very nice quality wise and it would be a fun commuter or project toy bike, but it just isn't better enough than even a GS to justify the $7K+ price.
I think if you got a YZF it would rapidly become your primary bike. The suspension and motor are in another league than the GSs.
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: jag69 on January 27, 2004, 01:07:33 PM
James your the man.  Thanks for the info.  If you ever find your way to southern AZ look me up.  That is if you can handle the heat. :cheers:

L8
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: BanannaMan on January 27, 2004, 04:37:55 PM
Motorcyclyst magazene says the 599 (and yamaha's new FZ6) are more in line with a bandit 600 than an SV.

I know 4 YZF600R owners...2 have replaced transmisions..the other 2 ...no trouble.
I looked at buying one but ended up getting an SVS because of that.
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: jag69 on January 27, 2004, 04:47:41 PM
Bananna Man.  How do you like the ergos of the SVS?  What is your opinion of the SVS compared to the GS?
Do they have risers for the SVS?
Thanks
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: BanannaMan on January 27, 2004, 07:50:47 PM
The SVS and the GS are very different bikes.
I like the ergos on the SVS better but I was always wishing the GS's bars were lower or further forward.
I also like the rearsets  on the SV better...... on long trips on the GS I would find it more comfortable to have my tiptoes on the pegs.
I have ridden both bikes on trips of 1800 miles or more and for me....the SVS is more comfortable(especially the seat)...but it's all in what you like personally.

It did take me a few thousand miles to get used to the v-twin..you MUST give it gas when down shifting....and that seems really un-natural when trying to slow down quickly.
The 600R will dust the SV above 120mph... but from 0-100 (which is where I ride the most) The SVS will leave a 600 and I have no problem scrapping with literbikes in the twisties.  (torque can be a good thing)

Still I like the look of the YZF and their less torquey 4cyl. is smoother than the SVS and probably closer to the GS's ride.
But knowing 2 people who had to replace trannys....and how far I ride alone...and the SV's are bullet proof....well.... you see what I got.





.
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: jag69 on January 27, 2004, 08:07:52 PM
The SV650S has always been on my list for "Next Bike", I just wasn't sure about the Ergos (clip-ons mainly).  I am in my 30's and l love to ride on the weekends 3 to 4 hours (I am a family man and I need to budget my time.)  My daily ride to work is only 5 miles one way ( I often make it double on purpose).  Thanks for the info.
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: JamesG on January 27, 2004, 08:37:23 PM
YZF tranny - Yes some do go out, but its mostly rider error that causes it. You have guys who have put 20K miles on thiers without any problems.  I have to admit that I have ground the gearbox a few times before I did the Factory "shift kit" and learned how it likes to be shifted.  I also knew of it before hand but wanted the the bike enough to take the chance.

Jag- Careful. I know some guys who can do Iron Butts on GSXR1Ks, doesn't mean everyone can or is willing to put up with it. My '00 SV, which is alot more GS like than the SVS, was a Buddha Loves You after a few hundred miles.
Between the two, an SV is probably better than a GS for really long haul slabbing, but neither is really optimal for the task.
Title: YZF600R opinions (JamesG, others?)
Post by: BanannaMan on January 27, 2004, 10:20:50 PM
Er...James may have a point.....perhaps I should mention I ride 150 miles or more everytime I crank the bike.
No slabbing though..(if I can help it) ;)
I'll take the longer 2-lane route. :thumb:

40's, older kids, still managing time...but I have a little more(see what you have to look forward too??).
I ride long afternoons on saturdays  6-8hrs. (usually on the Blue Ridge Parkway) and take a few trips a year.

I don't ride to work.