GStwin.com GS500 Message Forum

Main Area => General GS500 Discussion => Topic started by: grimah1w on September 21, 2013, 07:17:20 AM

Title: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: grimah1w on September 21, 2013, 07:17:20 AM
Did compression test, rt cylinder 125psi, left 120psi so it is above min spec in both and within allowable difference.  27,000 miles.

So, while I know I have a minor head gasket leak (oil is seeping on right side at head gasket area) why else would it be so down on power and run like crap?  Smokey gray exhaust low power, backfire/misfire at rev.

Right plug was fouled...super black

I recently cleaned the carbs and will do again.  Petcock could be suspect, I plan to bypass if only temporarily to isolate potential fault. 

Will check float height again during carb tear down.


Other ideas???


THANKS!

Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: Suzuki Stevo on September 21, 2013, 07:46:42 AM
When did you last check the valve clearance?
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: The Buddha on September 21, 2013, 08:22:38 AM
 :icon_lol: head gasket leak = huge surprise it even runs.
Cool.
Buddha.
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: grimah1w on September 22, 2013, 05:02:47 AM
Valve clearance check data - rt in = .002" , rt ex = .003" :  lt in = .003" ,  lt ex = .001". 
Checked on 20 Sep 13

I would call the head gasket a seep, rt cylinder, just enough oil to discolor a few of the cooling fins...head bolts loosened and re-torqued.

Again, comp test on a cold dry engine pulling 125 and 120


Top cover tiny o-rings 1mm - 4x6mm, one of them was pinched partially over the passage....both are now replaced.    Bowl heights measured and reset to ~14mm

Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: grimah1w on September 22, 2013, 05:16:29 AM
Also, just replaced plugs yesterday.

Believe issue is w carburation...   Seems rich just by smell.   Stock airbox and yoshimura pipe.  Fresh exhaust gaskets. 

When I cleaned the carbs, I pulled the main and pilot jets, carb cleaner and compressed air through the passages.   I am third owner so not 100% sure they are stock jets.   The needle and it's retaining clip and two plastic spacers in the slide/diaphragm assemble look exactly like stock photos.   

Anyway to be sure I have a stock main jet?   
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: radodrill on September 22, 2013, 06:21:13 AM
The rejetting wiki page (http://wiki.gstwins.com/index.php?n=Upgrades.Rejetting) lists the stock jet sizes and are also listed in parentheses on the parts fiche.  The actual jet sizes are stamped into the jet; so you can pull them and read what's installed.
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: grimah1w on September 22, 2013, 11:19:14 AM
Thanks very much radodrill!   
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ? NEW symptom
Post by: grimah1w on September 22, 2013, 11:50:23 AM
So, after an initial nice start up, she is back to smoking like a two stroke and super rich smell....

Come home from test ride and the oil smells like gas and is thin.   Level has increased to about 1/8" above the full hash...gas in crank case :-(

Draining oil...new oil and filter will come.

NOW
Time for carbs to come off and I am done messing around with them, time to take to a local and have them fitted with repair kits (2x $30 kit plus about 80 in labor).  Not a true "rebuild" I guess but I am not sure what else or where else to go with these.   Advice?

At this point I am certain carbs are my issue. Wrong?   

Rebuild kits and thorough professional cleaning a fix?    I do not know I f the previous owner has messed w mixture screws.   Do not expect the mixture screw would contribute to gas into crankcase...obviously something more major at issue... Like needle valve /float setting...
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ? NEW symptom
Post by: radodrill on September 22, 2013, 12:18:11 PM
Quote from: grimah1w on September 22, 2013, 11:50:23 AM
So, after an initial nice start up, she is back to smoking like a two stroke and super rich smell....

Come home from test ride and the oil smells like gas and is thin.   Level has increased to about 1/8" above the full hash...gas in crank case :-(

....

At this point I am certain carbs are my issue. Wrong?

Gas in the crankcase is a serious issue and indicates problem with the engine itself and not the carbs.  Earlier you mentioned a head gasket leak; this is likely part of the underlying problem.  I'd suggest holding of on messing with the carbs until you have the engine itself fixed.
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: grimah1w on September 22, 2013, 01:07:12 PM
Rado, thanks.  What is it that you think is likely reason for gas into crankcase other than fuel through carb (carb malfunction)?
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: radodrill on September 22, 2013, 01:26:15 PM
The carbs themselves only control the air/fuel ratio based on throttle position.  For gas to get into the crankcase would mean there is something messed up within the engine itself.  There are actually oil channels in the cylinder walls to supply oil to cool/lube the top end; so it could be that the head is loose allowing the oil and air/fuel to mix.

P.S. oil mixed with gas produces a lot of smoke (e.g. 2-stroke engines)
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: grimah1w on September 22, 2013, 07:29:01 PM
Really ... Am counting on fact that carbs control fuel flow and air flow as root of issue.

Only path to engine for fuel is through the carburetors, since there is excessive fuel and apparently fuel flowing while not "running" carbs seem logical issue.

yes, lots of smoke like a two stroke one of the symptoms, fuel mixing in the oil confirmed in earlier post...way excessive fuel flow...

On top of a fresh head gasket with another compression/leak down test to verify integrity of motor, Is carb cleaning and carb gasket and needle kit the right think to seek or is there some other level of "rebuild" I should be seeking?

Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: Big Rich on September 22, 2013, 07:55:39 PM
Actually.......

If the petcock isn't stopping fuel from flowing (left on prime position, faulty diaphragm, etc...) then the carbs become flooded. Flooded carb with no overflow tube means the gas has to go somewhere - and that leads it into the engine. Given enough time, gasoline will work past the piston rings and mix with the oil.
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: radodrill on September 22, 2013, 08:22:21 PM
Assuming there was nothing wrong with the engine, if the air/fuel mix was too rich you'd simply have poor performance.
The carbs simply meter the fuel, but they do not have any oil flowing through them so that is not where the oil and fuel are mixing.

Oil leaking out from the head gasket and the fact that the oil and fuel are mixing (evidenced by the smoke and gas smell in the oil) are all indicators of a problem with the engine.

First step should be to have the engine checked out; once that's all good, then if you have poor performance look at the carbs.


Quote from: Big Rich on September 22, 2013, 07:55:39 PM
If the petcock isn't stopping fuel from flowing (left on prime position, faulty diaphragm, etc...) then the carbs become flooded.
The floats should still stop fuel flow once the bowl are full.  Even if this has failed, and fuel has indeed seeped past the rings, this wouldn't explain why a lot of oil is mixing into the cylinder.

A leak in the head gasket and/or slightly loose cylinder head would explain it.
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: radodrill on September 22, 2013, 08:40:11 PM
Also think about this:
In the case of a leaking head gasket you can expect the following:

Since the OP has a known leaking head gasket, fixing this should be the very first course of action.

p.s. I'm a mechanical engineer.
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: Big Rich on September 22, 2013, 08:48:30 PM
Ok, ok..... I see that pushed a button. First off, thank you for stating that you are an engineer. I'm not doubting your intelligence by any means.

I can tell you from experience that a faulty petcock will not stop fuel the way it is intended to. And I can also say from experience that gasoline can get past a float valve, and flood the engine. It sucks, but it happens.

I was just suggesting what appeared to me as an obvious issue that begins with the petcock.
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: radodrill on September 22, 2013, 09:02:26 PM
Quote from: Big Rich on September 22, 2013, 08:48:30 PM
Ok, ok..... I see that pushed a button.

It's all good; no offense taken.

I'm well aware that faulty petcock and float valves can indeed flood the cylinder (and seep past the rings over time).  If the bike were spitting fuel out the exhaust and not starting, then the petcock and carbs would be the #1 and #2 items to check out.  The signs of oil burning with the fuel and known leaking head gasket point to that as the primary culprit; though that's not ruling out the possibility of a carb or petcock problem as well.
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: grimah1w on September 23, 2013, 08:25:48 PM
Big Rich I am with you.  I also happen to be an engineer but have very little carb experience .   Fuel injection or turbines more in my wheelhouse. 

Gas incorrectly metered into engine...seep into oil.

Really just want rebuild / overhaul advice.   Rad I got the motor.  Timing- check, compression- check, plugs - check,  exhaust - check.   Head gasket replaced torqued head - check. 

Carbs....hummm. To shop I guess. 

Thanks
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: Big Rich on September 23, 2013, 08:36:48 PM
The last set of carbs I rebuilt cost me around $50, but that was to replace every o ring inside of them. Interior cleaning and exterior cleaning costs were less than $10. Just have a clean / open work space and take your time.

It is odd to me that your right plug was the one fouled up, especially with gas in your oil. Usually it is the left carb to cause issues first. Could it be the float was sticking and flooding the mix?
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: Big Rich on September 23, 2013, 08:47:03 PM
Just thought of it Vinnie - have you checked your electrical system lately as well? You didn't mention it above, and a weak / faulty spark can foul a plug too.
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: gsJack on September 23, 2013, 09:44:53 PM
+1 Rich

I've been thinking spark for a while on this one myself.  I'd first check the plug wires for tightness in the coils starting with the right one, a common GS problem.  Possible right pick-up problem also.  Switch the coils, switch the plugs and see if the problem moves too.  If the gas isn't burning it has to go somewhere, maybe the sump?  Two problems at once can be confusing like a loose plug wire and leaking float valve at the same time. 

Too many Engineers spoils the pot sometimes.  :icon_lol:   
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: desync0 on September 23, 2013, 11:53:41 PM
I'd suspect the head gasket.

You said it was already weeping,  and you loosened and retorqued the head studs. In the car world that's a good way to blow a head gasket even if you do it one stud at a time.

Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: grimah1w on September 24, 2013, 03:05:36 AM
In previous post I mentioned I replaced head gasket and retorqued.  Cylinder head surface is not distorted...all spec.   Problem persisted.     Carbs off, headed to shop today
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: gsJack on September 24, 2013, 10:05:19 AM
Check those plug wires while your waiting for the carbs if you haven't already done it.  They should be so tight in coil you can't budge them, can't pull them out and can't turn them.  They are screwed in and bonded tight in place when new.  If they are loose that could be part of your problem.  Checking spark by the conventional method will show that pickup and module are probably OK but just because plugs spark when held to the head doesn't mean they will in the cylinder under pressure.

A leaking float valve (needle valve) will be flowing while running, they cause most trouble when parked and leaking.  After my 97 was parked a while out of service once after I got the 02 I checked the oil before starting it up and it was way overfull, I had left frame petcock in prime.  Bike was on centerstand, I think leak is to engine on stand and to the air box mostly with bike on ground, at least that's been my experience.

I use to be an engineer too but I retired 19 years ago and am just another shade tree mechanic now.   :icon_lol: 
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: grimah1w on October 04, 2013, 03:49:50 PM
And...the carbs returned from shop, all clean and with fresh full rebuild kits, installed and she fired right up, happy and running like a champ! 

Plug wires were good to go too!

Aersp Engs don't do carburetors! :-).   
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: The Buddha on October 04, 2013, 03:53:38 PM
Quote from: grimah1w on October 04, 2013, 03:49:50 PM

Aersp Engs don't do carburetors! :-).

Carbs are all about air flow ... 100% ... aerospace is the exact science it is.
Its a venturi ...
Cool.
Buddha.
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: radodrill on October 04, 2013, 04:25:31 PM
Quote from: grimah1w on October 04, 2013, 03:49:50 PMAersp Engs don't do carburetors! :-).
It's fluid mechanics of a converging-diverging nozzle with a variable throat restriction coupled with a downstream butterfly valve to regulate the airflow, which meters the fuel through ports by means of the Venturi effect.  Sure sounds like Aerospace Engineering to me.
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: grimah1w on October 04, 2013, 04:55:32 PM
Fluid dynamics and stoichiometry, yes, I am further pleased that not only did I properly recognize the source of the issue, as an aerospace engineer I had the sense to not waste my time on such inferior technology feeding an ICE, and just took it to the local witch-doctor :-D
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: The Buddha on October 04, 2013, 05:01:02 PM
Yes that's true too ... you can know all the theory and make a bloody good engineer, its a whole other skill set to be a mechanic. You sorta need to shelve the knowledge and work in the moment.

Cool.
Buddha.
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: Old Mechanic on October 04, 2013, 05:50:29 PM
Quote from: radodrill on October 04, 2013, 04:25:31 PM
Quote from: grimah1w on October 04, 2013, 03:49:50 PMAersp Engs don't do carburetors! :-).
It's fluid mechanics of a converging-diverging nozzle with a variable throat restriction coupled with a downstream butterfly valve to regulate the airflow, which meters the fuel through ports by means of the Venturi effect.  Sure sounds like Aerospace Engineering to me.

LOLOL, try this one.
http://www.google.com/patents/US7677208
It's a rotary infinitely variable in wheel regenerative hydraulic drive.

regards
Mech
Title: Re: Compression test OK - so why running like do do ?
Post by: grimah1w on October 05, 2013, 07:00:11 AM
Like it... still, more comfortable with a turbine engine and FADEC.

Since she is now clean and running, I may delve into minor tweaks.  My mechanic skills having been sufficient for all other tasks associated with this restoration, should enable me to get the mixture about right - notwithstanding my frustration experienced in the carb rebuilds :-)   

My OP is answered and I look forward to reading more on the forum.
best!
Vinnie