News:

Protect your dainty digits. Get a good pair of riding gloves cheap Right Here

Main Menu

Straight rate springs vs. Progressive rate

Started by Alphamazing, October 10, 2005, 03:24:51 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Alphamazing

I've searched and searched, but I can't seem to find out why everyone loves the progressive rate springs. The general consensus on the FZ1 board is that straight rate springs are preferred, which makes a lot of sense. Straight rate springs allow for much sportier riding without any question as to what's going to happen with the tension in the springs.

Thoughts? Opinions?
'05 DR-Z400SM (For Sale)
'04 GS500E (Sold)

Holy crap it's the Wiki!
http://wiki.gstwins.com/

scratch

You are correct. Most racers (and sporty-bike riders) use all of their suspension travel. With a straight rate spring you can actually estimate how much brake to use to dive the front end to the desired height and decrease the rake (and trail, or castor) to make turn-in (steering input) that much easier. It is also much easier to control when accelerating out of a turn.

Progressives are useful for anti-dive. As the softer, closer-together coils bind up together they become a solid spacer for the stiffer, more spaced out coils.
The motorcycle is no longer the hobby, the skill has become the hobby.

Power does not compare to skill.  What good is power without the skill to use it?

QuoteOriginally posted by Wintermute on BayAreaRidersForum.com
good judgement trumps good skills every time.

Alphamazing

Holy crap. An informative response... Sweet.

Why are the progressive rates preferred on this board, then? It's all I hear about.
'05 DR-Z400SM (For Sale)
'04 GS500E (Sold)

Holy crap it's the Wiki!
http://wiki.gstwins.com/

werase643

also since the GS has itsy bitsy teensy weensy fork tubes
it is not considered a great race bike....
therefore the AM company makes springs for street riders.
yes you probably can get straight rate...but why...get a diff front end
want Iain's money to support my butt in kens shop

Alphamazing

Quote from: werase643also since the GS has itsy bitsy teensy weensy fork tubes
it is not considered a great race bike....
therefore the AM company makes springs for street riders.
yes you probably can get straight rate...but why...get a diff front end

Front ends are expensive, springs are cheap, that's why! :)
'05 DR-Z400SM (For Sale)
'04 GS500E (Sold)

Holy crap it's the Wiki!
http://wiki.gstwins.com/

scratch

Quote from: AlphaFire X5Holy crap. An informative response... Sweet.

Why are the progressive rates preferred on this board, then? It's all I hear about.

Besides being very inexpensive, progresive rate springs are ideal for new riders such that they are soft enough to give a compliant and comfortable riding experience, but stiffen-up fast enough to control otherwise drastic chassis attitude changes and give a feeling of control and confidence.

On a side note: Progressives work very well in hiding warped front brake disks, by absorbing the undulations under braking.
The motorcycle is no longer the hobby, the skill has become the hobby.

Power does not compare to skill.  What good is power without the skill to use it?

QuoteOriginally posted by Wintermute on BayAreaRidersForum.com
good judgement trumps good skills every time.

Alphamazing

I think I'll just drop some shims in to stiffen up my springs then. Thank you!
'05 DR-Z400SM (For Sale)
'04 GS500E (Sold)

Holy crap it's the Wiki!
http://wiki.gstwins.com/


RVertigo

http://www.gstwin.com/making_fork_spacers.htm

:thumb:


I'm gonna do it someday...  I swear.   :oops:

I'd also like to get a thicker (less bendy) version of the plate (whatever the hell it's called) between the fork tubes.

Alphamazing

The Racetechs are $110! :O That's a bit too much for me. Spacers will be the mod of choice for me, I guess.
'05 DR-Z400SM (For Sale)
'04 GS500E (Sold)

Holy crap it's the Wiki!
http://wiki.gstwins.com/

RVertigo

I saw that too... The weight calculator RULES!  Type in your weight and it tells you the stock springs vs what you should get...

Too bad they're a bill plus shipping.   :(




:lol: According to the calculator, you'd have to weigh 44 Lbs for the stock springs to be right...  No wonder RG never complains about them    :lol:

Alphamazing

Is there a way to calculate the spacer size necessary to create a given spring weight?
'05 DR-Z400SM (For Sale)
'04 GS500E (Sold)

Holy crap it's the Wiki!
http://wiki.gstwins.com/

RVertigo

Do I look like I work for RaceTech?   :nana:

aaronstj

Just playing around with their weight calculator, I decided to find the rider weight that would make the recommended springs match the stock springs.

If you want to ride on the stock springs, Racetech recommends that you weight 44.5 lbs.

Good to know.
1992 Blue Monday, Wileyco, lunchbox, 150/40/3/1, Srinath bars, progressives, fenderectomy

Borak: How come Ogg use one spear, Borak need three?
Ogg: Not spear, caveman.

RVertigo

You must be as bored as I am...  (See two posts above).   :P

Alphamazing

Hmm. There must me a length/mass formula I could use to plug in spacer length. Anyone? Geniuses?
'05 DR-Z400SM (For Sale)
'04 GS500E (Sold)

Holy crap it's the Wiki!
http://wiki.gstwins.com/

John Bates

Quote from: AlphaFire X5..........Spacers will be the mod of choice for me, I guess.

I don't know much about springs but my gut tells me that a spacer will just reduce the available spring travel and the rate for the remaining travel isn't changed.  What do you gain?

:cheers:
----------------------------------------------------
Bikes don't leak oil, they mark their territory.  (Joerg)
----------------------------------------------------


2002 Harley Sportster XLH883 with V&H Straight Shots
Prior owner of 1992 GS500E stock
Fairfield County, OH
USA

Gisser

Quote from: AlphaFire X5Hmm. There must me a length/mass formula I could use to plug in spacer length. Anyone? Geniuses?

Yeah, your premise is wrong.  You can't stiffen the forks with a spacer.  It will raise the front, and it   may increase travel if the stock springs have any collapsible space left between the coils.   :roll:

RVertigo

The spacer is pretty small...  Just adds some pre-load...  Check the link.

Alphamazing

Quote from: Gisser
Quote from: AlphaFire X5Hmm. There must me a length/mass formula I could use to plug in spacer length. Anyone? Geniuses?

Yeah, your premise is wrong.  You can't stiffen the forks with a spacer.  It will raise the front, and it   may increase travel if the stock springs have any collapsible space left between the coils.   :roll:

Hm. Makes sense. I don't see why I didn't see that... I guess it'd be to remove some of the slack in the springs before they start to compress?
'05 DR-Z400SM (For Sale)
'04 GS500E (Sold)

Holy crap it's the Wiki!
http://wiki.gstwins.com/

SMF spam blocked by CleanTalk