News:

The simplest way to help GStwin is to use this Amazon link to shop

Main Menu

Synthetic dilemma

Started by stllplyswthcars, May 11, 2006, 03:48:50 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

stllplyswthcars

I recently asked my Suzuki dealer about using synthetic oil in my '04 GS.  He said I could't use synthetic becuase of the "wet clutch".  I have some buddies who say it's BS while others believe it.  Anyone out have an opinion or first-hand knowledge?   Thanks, Scott

TragicImage

#1
oh jesus.


first off, the search button is a friendly tool.


second off, this is a long and heated debate


Third, its your own personal choice.


fourth, Asians smell like cabbage


fifth, I'm running out of ideas

and

finally, The Suzuki Manual says nothing about "not" using synthetic, just that you use a properly rated oil.



http://gstwins.com/gsboard/index.php?action=search;advanced
Impeach Pandy

2006 GS500F


Hipocracy.... becoming more acceptable with the more power you think you have.

EMTkid

I don't think jesus has anything to do with it - unless the he's known to be a friction modifier :icon_lol:
Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy.
-Benjamin Franklin

TragicImage

uh, well, its a well known fact that jesus ran Synthetics.
Impeach Pandy

2006 GS500F


Hipocracy.... becoming more acceptable with the more power you think you have.

scratch

The motorcycle is no longer the hobby, the skill has become the hobby.

Power does not compare to skill.  What good is power without the skill to use it?

QuoteOriginally posted by Wintermute on BayAreaRidersForum.com
good judgement trumps good skills every time.

natedawg120

 :laugh: :laugh: :laugh: :laugh:

Note : I use and have used synthetic the entire time i have owned the bike (- the first 400 miles).  No clutch problems, no oil burning, runs like a champ and no sludge (yet).  I love synthetic.
Bikeless in RVA

EMTkid

Donkey, ducati - very close in Hebrew

The real question though: Between Jesus "our lord and savior" Christ and Valentino Rossi, who would win?
Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy.
-Benjamin Franklin

NiceGuysFinishLast

Quote from: TragicImage on May 11, 2006, 03:50:14 PM
oh jesus.


first off, the search button is a friendly tool.


second off, this is a long and heated debate


Third, its your own personal choice.


fourth, Asians smell like cabbage


fifth, I'm running out of ideas

and

finally, The Suzuki Manual says nothing about "not" using synthetic, just that you use a properly rated oil.



http://gstwins.com/gsboard/index.php?action=search;advanced


Hahahahahahhahahaha.... is it scary that my thought process went in almost the exact same direction? Oh yes. Asians really do smell like cabbage. *Sniffs self*.. Yep..
irc.freequest.net

#GStwins gs500

Hang out there, we may flame, but we don't hate.

My attitude is in serious need of readjustment, and I'm ok with that.

scratch

Rossi.  Jesus doesn't get to practice on his Ducati as much as he used to...see here: http://www.cycleforums.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=146662&highlight=jesus
The motorcycle is no longer the hobby, the skill has become the hobby.

Power does not compare to skill.  What good is power without the skill to use it?

QuoteOriginally posted by Wintermute on BayAreaRidersForum.com
good judgement trumps good skills every time.

RVertigo

Quote from: stllplyswthcars on May 11, 2006, 03:48:50 PMI recently asked my Suzuki dealer about using synthetic oil in my '04 GS.  He said I could't use synthetic becuase of the "wet clutch".  I have some buddies who say it's BS while others believe it.  Anyone out have an opinion or first-hand knowledge?   Thanks, Scott
Buncha smartasses around here...

It's easy for me:  I have two oil leaks...  I' too lazy/cheap to fix them...  Synthetic leaks a lot faster...  No synthetic for me!  :thumb:

If you search on "Synthetic Oil" you'll find 6 pages of threads on it...

I'd just go with the oil that the manual says to use...  Whatever that is...

natedawg120

#10
Quote from: RVertigo on May 11, 2006, 04:41:42 PM
Quote from: stllplyswthcars on May 11, 2006, 03:48:50 PMI recently asked my Suzuki dealer about using synthetic oil in my '04 GS.  He said I could't use synthetic becuase of the "wet clutch".  I have some buddies who say it's BS while others believe it.  Anyone out have an opinion or first-hand knowledge?   Thanks, Scott
Buncha smartasses around here...

It's easy for me:  I have two oil leaks...  I' too lazy/cheap to fix them...  Synthetic leaks a lot faster...  No synthetic for me!  :thumb:

If you search on "Synthetic Oil" you'll find 6 pages of threads on it...

I'd just go with the oil that the manual says to use...  Whatever that is...

Honestly there is probably a lot more this has been argued a lot since i have been around, I am still new :laugh: :laugh: :laugh:


Edit : oh oh oh search "oil".  You will learn everything you want to know from gas in oil and fouled plugs to cabling and fork oil  :laugh: :laugh: :laugh: :laugh: :cheers:
Bikeless in RVA

RVertigo

#11
Well, with my history of cars/bikes I don't have much to add to the argument...    Other than it was cool for the little time I used it in my F.O.R.D.

    85 Nissan Pulsar - Leaked Oil - No Synthetic
    69 VW bug - Leaked, sprayed, burned, and ate oil - No Synthetic
    79 Jeep Wagoneer - Leaked and burned oil - No Synthetic
    94 Ford Exploder - Didn't leak when I bought it...  Ran Synthetic for a while and it ran WAY better, smoother, everything you'd ever dream of...  Started leaking, fixed leak...  New leak, fixed leak...  New leak, screw it - No Synthetic
    68 H#nda CT90 - Leaked and burned oil - No Synthetic
    79 H#nda CT90 - Burned oil - No Synthetic
    01 Suzuki GS500 - Leaks oil - No Synthetic
    [/list]

    natedawg120

    Quote from: RVertigo on May 11, 2006, 04:50:16 PM
    Well, with my history of cars/bikes I don't have much to add to the argument...    Other than it was cool for the little time I used it in my F.O.R.D.

      87 Nissan Pulsar - Leaked Oil - No Synthetic
      69 VW bug - Leaked, sprayed, burned, and ate oil - No Synthetic
      79 Jeep Wagoneer - Leaked and burned oil - No Synthetic
      94 Ford Exploder - Didn't leak when I bought it...  Ran Synthetic for a while and it ran WAY better, smoother, everything you'd ever dream of...  Started leaking, fixed leak...  New leak, fixed leak...  New leak, screw it - No Synthetic
      68 H#nda CT90 - Leaked and burned oil - No Synthetic
      79 H#nda CT90 - Burned oil - No Synthetic
      01 Suzuki GS500 - Leaks oil - No Synthetic
      [/list]

      Thats it, you used synthetic in a Ford.  All i have to say is ....... ITS A FORD :laugh: :laugh: :laugh: :laugh: :laugh: :laugh:
      Bikeless in RVA

      natedawg120

      Damnit, i hate amd love beer i wanted to quote my own reply
      Bikeless in RVA

      EMTkid

      The big G man knows whats up

      Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy.
      -Benjamin Franklin

      FearedGS500

      to answer what has been asked is ... i run simisynecthic stuff in my  bike and have no problem .. i'v heard its not good to start running a full syenthitic on an old cluch ( old being has a few thosand miles on it )  because its  rough on the warn cluch

      tkm433

      Quote from: stllplyswthcars on May 11, 2006, 03:48:50 PM
      I recently asked my Suzuki dealer about using synthetic oil in my '04 GS.  He said I could't use synthetic becuase of the "wet clutch".  I have some buddies who say it's BS while others believe it.  Anyone out have an opinion or first-hand knowledge?   Thanks, Scott

      If you use motorcycle specific synthetic oils designed to work in wet clutch applications you will have no problems.
      Here is a copy and paste for Mobil 1
      [/color][/size]
      "Mobil 1 V-Twin 20W-50 is recommended for four-cycle motorcycles that specify the use of a 20W-50 engine oil. It provides excellent performance in motorcycle engines that are designed with a common engine/transmission lubrication system or where the engine lubrication system is separate from the transmission system. In the case of the latter, follow the manufacturer's recommendation for the type of fluid to be used in the transmission. Mobil 1 V-Twin 20W-50 engine oil is also designed to provide the proper frictional characteristics necessary for wet-clutch engine/transmission systems. Mobil 1 V-Twin 20W-50 exceeds the requirements of API Service Categories SH, SG/CF, CD and has been fully tested, both on laboratory dynamometers and in the field, to provide optimum horsepower and acceleration.

      Fully synthetic Mobil 1 motorcycle oils are specifically engineered for use in motorcycles. The formulations are based on the proven technology used in other Mobil 1 automotive products, yet they are optimized for the unique requirements of a motorcycle engine and/or transmission. You can use them with confidence, knowing they will protect your bike in extreme situations where conventional motor oils simply can not stand up, including extended high-speed operation and prolonged idling in summertime traffic. "


      Here is what Suzuki has to say about their Synthetic oil:
      [/b][/color][/size]
      Full synthetic lubricant developed for high performance 4-cycle motorcycles and ATVs, providing excellent engine protection, cleanliness and outstanding clutch and gearbox operation. Special formulation helps prevent clutch slippage and reduces clutch sticking after cold starts. Meets or exceeds: API SF/SG; SH/SJ with JASO MA

      Part #: 990A0-10W40-R1Q


      Now ask your self a little question: Would Mobil and Suzuki and all of the other motorcycle companies offer synthetic oils if they would harm their products?  Would most if not all motorcycle race teams use synthetic oil if they had nothing to gain from its use?

      If you want to have fun go to the Suzuki dealer that told you that you could not use synthetic oil due to your wet clutch and ask him why SUZUKI sells SYNTHETIC OIL.  Ask him to check the price on this part number 990A0-10W40-R1Q and then ask him what this part number is for.

      Phaedrus

      I am not even going to comment on the synthetic oil debate in this thread.

      However, I would like to make a motion that TragicImage not be allowed to welcome new members anymore.  Frankly, he sucks at it and should not be part of the welcoming committee  :flipoff:  :icon_razz:
      Richard died in a motorcycle accident that was at no fault of his own.  We lost a good friend and good member of this board.  Though Rich may be gone, his legacy will live on here.

      Photos from the June '06 Northeast GStwin Meet


      GeeP

      QuoteAnyone out have an opinion or first-hand knowledge?   Thanks, Scott

      Pour some cheap service SF in it and go for a ride.   ;)

      Change your oil often and don't flog the thing to death.  Do your maintenace per the manual, and keep a record for future reference.  Take the money you would have spent on $12 a quart oil and "premium" gasoline and put it into an overhaul fund.   :)
      Every zero you add to the tolerance adds a zero to the price.

      If the product "fails" will the product liability insurance pay for the "failure" until it turns 18?

      Red '96
      Black MK2 SV

      SMF spam blocked by CleanTalk