News:

Need a manual?  Buy a Haynes manual Here

Main Menu

Sue The County? I mean, notify them...

Started by JasonD, May 24, 2006, 02:02:41 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

JasonD

Do you think I could sue the county if I were going down a mountain road at the posted speed limit, and hit a patch of sand and broke myself?

Just wondering since I almost flew off the side of bogus basin road today. There was a few corners with just enough sand to make you get wiggly...

Glad I wasn't driving too fast through that section, could have been a bad day.

Edit - - - Maybe I should notify them so no one else gets hurt, so that someone that isn't driving safe wont kill themselves. BTW, it's a joke, for all the jerks out there.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
2006 GS500F - Blue/White - No Mods
Caldwell, Idaho

Mitch

You can sue anyone for anything.  Will you win? probly not.
01 GS500.

Jake D

No.  The county likely has governmental immunity from suit.  There are only two exception to this rule: the negligent operation of a governmental motor vehicle, and maintaining a dangerous condition on governmental property.  And even under those exceptions, there are caps on liability (but they are around 300K). 

But I don't claim to know where you live or the laws of your state.  You should consult an attorney in your state. 
2003 Honda VTR1000F Super Hawk 996

Many of the ancients believe that Jake D was made of solid stone.

Onlypastrana199

Someone sued the county I live in because when they paved they left a rumble strip like mark in the lane not on the edge like on the highway and a biker hit it and totaled their bike...they won..$50k and they had to fix the road
'93 cf two bros can, alsa cobalt blue custom paint, fenderectomy, repositioned directionals, 15t sprocket, ignition advancer, SM2's, national cycle f-16 dark sport, cbr rearsets - fully rebuilt after a crash

Jake D

Do you think that is different than having sand on the road?

Or do you think that that is maintaining a dangerous condition on governmental property? 
2003 Honda VTR1000F Super Hawk 996

Many of the ancients believe that Jake D was made of solid stone.

Onlypastrana199

Prolly way different than the sand, of course you can't sue in NY between October and the end of May for anything having to do with road conditions.
'93 cf two bros can, alsa cobalt blue custom paint, fenderectomy, repositioned directionals, 15t sprocket, ignition advancer, SM2's, national cycle f-16 dark sport, cbr rearsets - fully rebuilt after a crash

Jake D

The roads in Kansas City are so f'ed up that what you want to do is drive in the pot holes and try to avoid the patches of pavement. 
2003 Honda VTR1000F Super Hawk 996

Many of the ancients believe that Jake D was made of solid stone.

CirclesCenter

Screw it, sue them. Get somebody good and you'll will

"If chewbacca does not make sense you must acquit!"  :bowdown:
Rich, RIP.

Wrecent_Wryder

#8
4f
"On hiatus" in reaction to out-of-control moderators, thread censorship and member bans, 7/31/07.
Your cure is worse than the disease.
Remember, no one HAS to contribute here.

corndog67

You might as well join the masses and sue them so our taxes can go up.  Every body else does.  It doesn't matter that you are in control of the bike, part of knowing how to ride is to judge the available traction and adjust your speed accordingly.  If you crash on sand or gravel in the road, it's your fault, dumbass.

ajgs500

Dude what the f%$k is your problem????

corndog67

My problem?  Some one almost crashes because of a lack of experience and riding skills and it is the counties fault?  How about trying a little personal responsibility on for size? 

ajgs500

How about you quit calling people dumbasses???  Is that necessary???

corndog67

That is a major problem in this country.  I did something stupid and I think I will sue someone.  That is a dumbass.  I'm done with you.

ajgs500

Good you need to brush up on your grammer.

makenzie71

I don't understand how you can have any grudge agains thte county after admitting you had already experienced a couple curves with sand on the road.  Do you remember when you took your driver's test?  Yeah one of the questions was "is the posted speed limit appropriate at all times?"  Remember that one?  It's not.  The posted speed limit is appropriate for nominal conditions only...that means if it's dark, stormy, windy, foggy or if there's sand on the road it's not considered safe to drive the posted speed limit.

FearedGS500

theres no point in trying to sue . the county can not keep every road clean ..  that i know of .. i dont think they clean a road . id say its not worth it . . just watch the road look ahead if you see somthing slow down  and procced with  care

poormanracing

#17
sue?....oh pls :icon_rolleyes:....just continue to be alert while riding and slow down....its part of riding a motorcycle....or just go back to your car...

JasonD

First of all, I had never been on that road before, except in a car. If I go around a corner at the posted safe speed limit I expect to be able to go around that corner without sliding off the thing when I've taken about 45-50 corners on that same road that didn't have sand on them. The only reason I didn't bust my ass on that road was because I was riding safely. I came around a corner at a safe speed cautiously and still almost managed to wreck my bike because the road wasn't clear of an obviously unsafe condition. If a car had come around that corner in my lane and hurt me, I'd have sued the shaZam! out of him for being stupid and driving in the wrong lane. If an unsafe condition exists that the county could have prevented, i.e. clearing all of the sand off that it dumped on the road to give drivers traction during snowy conditions (should have been cleared 6 weeks ago when the snow was completely melted), I wouldn't have brought it up. Thanks to all the people that automatically assumed I was driving fast and being stupid. That's the same attitude I see from most cage drivers, when they see a bike smashed into some guy's door because the bike didn't have time to react.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
2006 GS500F - Blue/White - No Mods
Caldwell, Idaho

makenzie71

Quote.... If I go around a corner at the posted safe speed limit I expect to be able to go around that corner without sliding off the thing...

What a wonderful way to die.

Here's something you need to clue into:  It is NOT the county's job to prevent you from being stupid.

SMF spam blocked by CleanTalk