News:

The simplest way to help GStwin is to use this Amazon link to shop

Main Menu

Oil Mystery

Started by shadow8586, December 15, 2014, 05:39:00 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

shadow8586

I have had kinda a mystery on my hands concerning my oil. I recently put a new engine into my GS500F we added 3 quarts of 10w40 oil to it. Didn't really check it the oil level figured it was fine. About a month ago I notice I was a little low and add about a quarter of a quart to it. Only to find out last week before I made a big trip that I was almost completely empty. I had nothing on the dipstick. I add a full quart of oil to it and it made it about half way to three quarters of the way to full. I have had no leaks or anything coming from the engine since the rebuild. I have read on line that even after adding three quarts that some people have to add a little more when it is warm. What would make me run out of a quart of oil? Also if my oil was that low wouldn't my oil  light come on? Also what is the best way to check the oil. I have heard on the center stand. I have heard straight up just sitting on it. Also, the next question that I am curious about is do I check it hot or cold? Considering that the bike is leaning to the left when it is on it's kickstand how much time should I give the oil to level out?

Thanks.

PantheraLeo

Were you reading it with the bike on the side stand, by chance?  It reads much different than on the center stand.  I read it only in the center stand. 

Also, the oil light only measures oil pressure, not oil level.  So you could be very low on oil but not see the light.

From Haynes Manual:



Go buy one of these.  You can do it through GsTwins and the site benefits!

Roaring via Tapatalk.

Katana 600 rear shock, 0.85 Sonic Springs
Shortened Signal Stalks
Fenderectomy
Fairing Repair/repaint
Yoshimura

twocool

New or newly rebuilt engines can and usually do have high oil consumption until they "break in"...in fact the reduction in consumption is an indication that the break in is complete...


The oil light shows oil pressure, not oil volume.....so even with a quart or two low, you may have enough oil pressure to keep the light off.....but running with too little oil is dangerous and it is possible to get a sudden drop in pressure with low oil volume...


The oil should be checked with the engine warmed up to normal operating temperature, and then shut off and left to sit for 4 minutes or so, so the oil drains back into the bottom of the engine...


Mine reads a bit HIGHER when warm...(hot oil expands??)

You should check the oil with the bike held level, front to back and side to side level....on its own wheels, not on center stand, not on side stand...


You unscrew the oil cap/dipstick and wipe clean... then insert the dip stick into the engine, but DO NOT SCREW IT IN....just let is sit...then check level...

When I have the bike on the side stand, and I check the oil...I hold the bike level for maybe 20 seconds, for the oil to settle level in the sump..

Cookie






Quote from: shadow8586 on December 15, 2014, 05:39:00 AM
I have had kinda a mystery on my hands concerning my oil. I recently put a new engine into my GS500F we added 3 quarts of 10w40 oil to it. Didn't really check it the oil level figured it was fine. About a month ago I notice I was a little low and add about a quarter of a quart to it. Only to find out last week before I made a big trip that I was almost completely empty. I had nothing on the dipstick. I add a full quart of oil to it and it made it about half way to three quarters of the way to full. I have had no leaks or anything coming from the engine since the rebuild. I have read on line that even after adding three quarts that some people have to add a little more when it is warm. What would make me run out of a quart of oil? Also if my oil was that low wouldn't my oil  light come on? Also what is the best way to check the oil. I have heard on the center stand. I have heard straight up just sitting on it. Also, the next question that I am curious about is do I check it hot or cold? Considering that the bike is leaning to the left when it is on it's kickstand how much time should I give the oil to level out?

Thanks.

ohgood

Quote from: shadow8586 on December 15, 2014, 05:39:00 AM
I have had kinda a mystery on my hands concerning my oil. I recently put a new engine into my GS500F we added 3 quarts of 10w40 oil to it.

1)a) Didn't really check it the oil level figured it was fine.
   b)About a month ago I notice I was a little low and add about a quarter of a quart to it.

2) Only to find out last week before I made a big trip that I was almost completely empty. I had nothing on the dipstick.

3) I add a full quart of oil to it and it made it about half way to three quarters of the way to full. I have had no leaks or anything coming from the engine since the rebuild. I have read on line that even after adding three quarts that some people have to add a little more when it is warm.

4) What would make me run out of a quart of oil?
5) Also if my oil was that low wouldn't my oil  light come on?
6) Also what is the best way to check the oil. I have heard on the center stand. I have heard straight up just sitting on it.
7) Also, the next question that I am curious about is do I check it hot or cold?
8) Considering that the bike is leaning to the left when it is on it's kickstand how much time should I give the oil to level out?

Thanks.

1a- huh ? new engine, did not check ? recalculating....
1b- adding oil when low is a good idea.

2- incorrect. 'off the stick' and 'empty' are not the same thing. you were likely 1/3 of a quart down from FULL.

3- see 2

4- riding it, it's an air cooled engine, it burns oil while at speed

5- no. oil pressure light, NOT oil level light.

6- level ground, with you sitting on it OR the center stand. always check in the same position.

7- always check it on two occasions:
a) after refueling (see google for tclocks)
and
b) after ending your riding for the day

the reasons for this are two fold: you'll have an idea of your consumption throughout a long ride, and you'll know it's oil level for tomorrows ride.

8- see 6



additional, the oil is checked by unscrewing the dipstick completely, wiping it off, PLACING IT ON THE THREADS (not screwing it in!) and then checking the level.


tt_four: "and believe me, BMW motorcycles are 50% metal, rubber and plastic, and 50% useless

Ron888

Quote from: twocool on December 15, 2014, 05:53:12 AM
DO NOT SCREW IT IN

Thanks! I've always wondered about that exact subtlety.My workshop manual doesnt explain that!

twocool




Get an owner's manual from the internet........

It explains lots of those kinds of things.....

Cookie






Quote from: Ron888 on December 15, 2014, 06:41:03 AM
Quote from: twocool on December 15, 2014, 05:53:12 AM
DO NOT SCREW IT IN

Thanks! I've always wondered about that exact subtlety.My workshop manual doesnt explain that!

sledge

When it comes to oil usage there needs to be some distinction between burning and evaporating. Thrash a good condition GS5 through the desert all day and it will evaporate more oil than it burns, totally normal owing to the design and nature of the engine but not oils are the same and some oils are more prone to evaporation than others.

Air cooled engines running in hot ambients need an oil with a low volatility (or evaporation rate). Mobil1 is amongst the best of the SAE40s

http://www.motorcyclenews.com/new-rider/2010/december/dec1510-know-your-bikes-oil-consumption-/


Atesz792

Quote from: sledge on December 15, 2014, 03:02:14 PM
When it comes to oil usage there needs to be some distinction between burning and evaporating. Thrash a good condition GS5 through the desert all day and it will evaporate more oil than it burns, totally normal owing to the design and nature of the engine but not oils are the same and some oils are more prone to evaporation than others.

Air cooled engines running in hot ambients need an oil with a low volatility (or evaporation rate). Mobil1 is amongst the best of the SAE40s

http://www.motorcyclenews.com/new-rider/2010/december/dec1510-know-your-bikes-oil-consumption-/
Well said. Their 20w-50 is amongst the best in its category, too.
'04 GS500F with 50k miles updated July 2022.
Ride it like a 2 stroke:
1: Rev high
2: Add oil
3: Repeat

Elmojo

Is it safe to use the Mobil1 automotive oil in the GS, or do I need to get the MC-specific stuff?
Isn't 20w-50 too heavy, especially for winter riding?
Sorry to threadjack, but I'm expecting to face similar issues to the OP on my project bike. :)

Old Mechanic

Motorcyle specific or your clutch will give you a fit.

regards
mech

Janx101


Elmojo

That's what I've always heard, but one of the FAQs (on GStwin.com I think) said it's fine to use Auto oil, as long as it's not 'energy conserving' or 'friction modified'.

Quote from: Old Mechanic on December 15, 2014, 09:21:47 PM<blockquote>Motorcyle specific or your clutch will give you a fit.

regards
mech
</blockquote>

Atesz792

You're good, you wouldn't use energy conserving anythingW-30 anyway.
Diesel/HDEO is better (and cheaper) than PCMO (additive package, shear stability, etc).
Just look for the petrol rating, too!
Like: API CI-4/SL
If you want to be absolutely sure, look for the Allison C4 rating on it, too. That's a wet clutch transmission test for certain big rigs.
'04 GS500F with 50k miles updated July 2022.
Ride it like a 2 stroke:
1: Rev high
2: Add oil
3: Repeat

Elmojo

I was wondering if the diesel oil comment would pop up.
I always ran Mobil Delvac in my '02 Bandit 1200, with no issues at all.
I'll probably (after whatever I use for testing and such) go with that same oil on the GS, unless you guys think that's a bad idea.
I'm all for using the right tool for the job, but not when the 'right tool' is twice the cost for no real benefit.
It's always seemed to be that motorcycle specific oils are pricey because they can be, not because they're really all that different from other motor oils.
Please correct me if I'm wrong. After all, I'm hear to learn. :)
-Mike

P.S. - Sorry to threadjack Shadow, I'm hoping some of this info is useful to you as well.

Janx101

Valvoline Super Diesel 15/40 with zero issues, almost no oil loss (300ml/5000km) and silky gear changes STILL! -1000km till next service. .. maybe I'm just lucky.... the oil is described as for high temp high km diesel engines. .  But the bike loves it. .. Jaso rated also

Elmojo

Nice! I'll see if I can find that around here.
Sounds like it might be what we call "premium blue" over on this side of the pond.

gsJack

#16
My 02 GS has gone 100k miles on JASO-MA rated 15W-40 Rotella T available at any Walmart or auto parts store.  Same type of heavy duty, truck, diesel type of oil as Janx's Valvoline and as all the other major oil companies make.

See the addendum at the bottom of this article:

http://www.vfrworld.com/tex_vfr/tech/oil.htm
407,400 miles in 30 years for 13,580 miles/year average.  Started riding 7/21/84 and hung up helmet 8/31/14.

Ron888

Yes that's what i've always heard and read.My GS500 workshop manual only talks about API classification motor oil. That said,using specific bike rated oils can only be better

Quote from: Elmojo on December 16, 2014, 07:48:37 AM
That's what I've always heard, but one of the FAQs (on GStwin.com I think) said it's fine to use Auto oil, as long as it's not 'energy conserving' or 'friction modified'.

Quote from: Old Mechanic on December 15, 2014, 09:21:47 PM<blockquote>Motorcyle specific or your clutch will give you a fit.

regards
mech
</blockquote>

Ron888

I too have always wondered about diesel oils.Occasionally we'll use some to top up one of dad's petrol vehicles because we've heard it is 'better' the normal car oil (assuming equal ratings),and we just happen to have some close by. I never did find out if it's true!

I've never tried diesel oil in a bike.
I simply use normal car oils because i always treat my best vehicles with XcelPlus- the only engine oil additive i've found that truly works.

Janx101

I mainly use the valentine because I have a 44gallon drum of it! For trucks I had.  Lol. .. but it happens to work well in the bike, as the others have said the brand isn't as important as the number rating and the type rating...

Like that royal purple for cars and such. .  Its might be good oil.. but what it especially is. .. is good marketing!

BTW I have used the oil in the trucks for a combined 1.9 million km over 20 years with no actual oil related problems

SMF spam blocked by CleanTalk